Tivaivai: The Social Fabric of the Cook Islands. Susanne Küchler and Andrea Eimke

Tivaivai: The Social Fabric of the Cook Islands. Susanne Küchler and Andrea
Eimke. London: The British Museum Press, 2009. 118 pp.*
Reviewed by Marsha MacDowell
Over the last fifty years the study of the production and meaning of quilts has been expanding
exponentially both in breadth and depth. Studies of quilt-related activity in regions, in cultures,
in families, and of individuals heretofore unexplored or under-investigated are contributing to
our understanding of those regions, cultures, familial relationships, and individuals in ways
previously unimagined or impossible.
This volume builds on and drills deeper into previous studies of the history and culture of the
inhabitants of a very small geographic region—the Cook Islands, an archipelago of islands
located in the Pacific and with a land mass of only 240 square kilometers—and focuses on how
its patchwork and quilting traditions of tivaivai represent a social fabric that, in a variety of ways,
sustains a sense of community, history, and identity for Cook Islanders no matter where they live
in the world.
The volume has two authors who, as described on the back cover, combine “artistic and
anthropological perspectives” with Susanne Küchler, a professor of anthropology at University
College London, ostensibly contributing the anthropological perspective and Andrea Eimke,
identified as an artist and embroiderer having lived in the islands for 25 years, as presumably
providing the artistic perspective. Their contributions are not blended into one voice but, rather,
Küchler’s writing is presented as a continuous essay while Eimke’s contributions are scattered
throughout within framed text boxes or sidebars. This side-by-side presentation of perspectives is
almost as interesting as the content itself. Both writers are sharing closely observed descriptions
and analyses of the place and meaning of tivaivai in the Cook Islands; one from the theoretically
informed viewpoint of an academically trained ethnographer, the other from the perspective of a
community lay ethnographer, a person who has been a participant-observer deeply enmeshed in
the culture and, specifically, the tradition of tivaivai over a sustained period. Together their
insights and analyses provide the reader with the history and meaning of tivaivai that is thorough,
scholarly, and accessible.
Cook Islands tivaivai looks at once similar yet different from patchwork and appliqué quilt
traditions found elsewhere. As within other Pacific Island areas and, indeed, within indigenous
communities in North America, the Pacific, South Africa and likely other regions impacted by
trade exploration, colonization and the spread of Christianity, quiltmaking was introduced by
Western European or Euro-American missionaries and traders. And, as in indigenous groups
elsewhere, Cook Islanders adapted the basic construction techniques of quilts but modificd both
the designs and uses in ways that were unmistakably linked to their culture. Whether made of
thousands of colored squares of cloth arranged in fractal patterns or fashioned of cut snowflakelike
appliquéd designs heavily edged with embroidered or crocheted thread, tivaivai is a visual
art distinctive to its locale. For Cook Islanders, tivaivai are also inextricably tied to the exchange
* This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 3.0 Unported
License. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/ or send a letter to
Creative Commons, 171 Second Street, Suite 300, San Francisco, California, 94105, USA.
Museum Anthropology Review 5(1-2) Spring-Fall 2011
136
of gifts, the honoring of those who are going through rites of passage, or who hold places of
esteem in society. As Küchler astutely states, “The geometrical and mathematical construction of
Cook Islands tivaivai, so eloquently exhibited in their symmetrical and fractal composition,
reflect in large measure the fabric’s indexical and symbolic value as an agent of temporal
reckoning. Tivaivai patterns enable the recall of certain events associated with key moments in
women’s lives and encode ways of categorizing social relations that unfold in the vicinity of the
quilts” (p. 15). And, as equally perceptive, Eimke states, in speaking of her own personal
awakening of the meaning of tivaivai in the Cook Islands, “The appreciation of the work and
time involved [in making tivaivai] is not the chief concern here. It is the person who receives it
that is” (p. 53).
Tivaivai, in both their physicality and in their meaning and use, expose us to ideas and theories
that, as Küchler posits, help us understand “how societies in the Pacific have turned themselves
into thriving transnational societies” that sustain economic and cultural flows between the island
homelands and the many places around the world where diasporic Cook Islanders now live.
Much as a Star quilt of mostly Plains Indian origin now serves for Native Americans of many
different tribal backgrounds as a symbol of sense of pan-Indian identity and solidarity with an
indigenous heritage, to a Cook Islander, tivaivai instantly conjures up home, a cultural identity
and specific worldviews.
That the volume is written by two women and is about women, is a point that is important to
highlight. As Küchler states “Perhaps it is because the European observers and missionaries who
populated the Cook Islands between 1850 and the present day are predominantly male that we
know so little about the role that women played in shaping and integrating an increasingly
diasporic society” (p. 8). Küchler and Eimke have constructed a beautifully rendered study of
perhaps one of the most visible and important art forms of the Cook Islands, one that has been
shaped by women and which in term has played a significant role in sustaining a culture that
might at times feel vulnerable to change or disappearance.
Sidebars and chapters are devoted to tivaivai as the fabric of friendship, as a means of mapping
time and space, as evidence of acknowledged mastery of skill and creativity, and as reflections of
the flora of the islands. Other sections highlight the history and activities of church groups,
associations, and the Atiu Fibre Arts Studio that have been devoted to making and exhibiting
tivaivai, and examine the ways in which tivaivai is influencing the work of artists in other media.
Maps and photographs of the islands, historical and contemporary photographs of examples of
tivaivai being made and used, and portraits of the makers help contextualize the work and
Eimke’s deeply personal stories humanize the text and reinforce the living nature of the tradition.
The one very disappointing note to this volume is with Küchler’s reference, beginning in the
opening paragraphs to her essay, to the widely-distributed myth of the last decade that, as
Küchler states, “quilts [were] made by Afro-American slaves to encode, in the stitched patterns,
the pathways to freedom known evocatively as the ‘underground railroad’ (p. 1). This notion,
based on one woman’s story told in the late 1980s to a writer, has become uncritically accepted
and wildly popular nearly throughout the world. Yet it is a story that has been thoroughly
disputed by countless scholars specializing in U.S. Civil War history, African American slavery
studies, and quilt history. Küchler returns to this idea later in her essay and speaks of it as
Museum Anthropology Review 5(1-2) Spring-Fall 2011
137
accepted fact and thus, sadly, she, along with the British Museum Press, have now become
additional voices of authority who unknowingly are complicit in the perpetuation of this
falsehood.
References Cited
Hammond, Joyce D.
1986 Tifaifai and Quilts of Polynesia. Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press.
Rongokea, L.
2001 [1992] The Art of Tivaevae: Traditional Cook Islands Quilting. Honolulu: University of
Hawaii Press.
Pogglioli, Vicki
1990 [1988] Patterns from Paradise: The Art of Tahitian Quilting. Pittstown, NJ: Main Street
Press.
Marsha MacDowell is Professor of Art and Art History at the Michigan State University and
Curator of Folk Arts at the Michigan State University Museum.